Understanding "extern variable initialization is not allowed" in MQL5
When working with MQL5, you might encounter the error message "extern variable initialization is not allowed." This error typically arises during the compilation stage, indicating a fundamental misunderstanding of how extern
variables are declared and used within MQL5. Let's delve into the reasons behind this error and how to properly handle extern
variables.
What are extern
Variables?
extern
variables in MQL5 are a mechanism for sharing data between different Expert Advisors (EAs) or indicators. When declared as extern
, a variable becomes accessible from all scripts and programs running within the same terminal instance.
Imagine a shared database where different applications can access and modify the same information. That's similar to how extern
variables work.
Why Can't You Initialize extern
Variables Directly?
The core reason behind the "extern variable initialization is not allowed" error is that extern
variables are not directly assigned values within the code where they are declared.
Consider this:
-
extern
variables reside in the global scope. Their values are set and retrieved through external means – typically via the MetaTrader 5 terminal settings or input parameters. -
If you were to initialize an
extern
variable directly within your code, this would create a conflict. Imagine two different scripts trying to assign different values to the sameextern
variable! This would lead to inconsistent behavior and unpredictable outcomes.
How to Correctly Use extern
Variables
To avoid the "extern variable initialization is not allowed" error and leverage extern
variables effectively, follow these steps:
-
Declare the
extern
Variable:- Use the
extern
keyword to declare the variable, specifying its data type. - Do not assign any initial values to the variable.
extern int MyExternalVariable;
- Use the
-
Define the Variable's Value:
- Assign the
extern
variable a value through one of these methods:- MetaTrader 5 Terminal Settings: Access the expert advisor's settings within the terminal and input a value for the
extern
variable. - Input Parameters: Define the
extern
variable as aninput
parameter in your script, allowing users to set values through the Strategy Tester or directly in the terminal.
- MetaTrader 5 Terminal Settings: Access the expert advisor's settings within the terminal and input a value for the
input int MyInputVariable = 10; // Example of defining value through input parameter
- Assign the
-
Access the Variable:
- Within your MQL5 code, simply reference the
extern
variable by its name.
int MyLocalVariable = MyExternalVariable + 5; // Accessing the value from the `extern` variable
- Within your MQL5 code, simply reference the
Example: Using extern
to Share a Trading Strategy Setting
// EA Script
extern int EntryThreshold; // Declares the `extern` variable
input int StopLoss = 20; // Defines another variable as an input
void OnInit()
{
// Access the `extern` variable
if (EntryThreshold < 5)
{
Print("Entry threshold is too low, adjusting...");
EntryThreshold = 5;
}
}
In this example, EntryThreshold
can be adjusted by the user through the MetaTrader 5 terminal settings, allowing for customization of the entry threshold across multiple EAs using the shared value.
Conclusion
The "extern variable initialization is not allowed" error in MQL5 stems from the fundamental design of extern
variables. These variables are designed for sharing information between scripts and rely on external sources like terminal settings or input parameters for their values. By understanding this concept and following the correct usage guidelines, you can effectively leverage extern
variables for creating flexible and customizable MQL5 programs.